Hi!
(I a beginner commander, I have only 50+ commander wins on this server.)
I played sometimes as a really "lame" team: no or only 1-2 normal/pro players and the other 10-15 is beginner player, no aim skill, don't go waypoint, if he have a GL/HMG and door opening, wait for 40 sec. for a JP/HA and dont use the weapon.
I see 1 times we played on ns_siege007 and many, 4-8 marines have GL/HMG and wait on base for HA and the aliens kill PG and kill RTs and the marines only wait on base (currently I died 3 times on front

)... Unsichtbar was a commander and he wrote: "Marines wait for summer" or same and he sell the base and end game. I think he do a one of solution what can make a commander on this situation, but I searching a workable thing what other can I do this situation.
If I wrote: "Go front" or "Go to door" or "Repair PG with welder" and put WayPoints - a lot of marine STILL WAIT WITH top weapon on the base for HA/JP and don't move....
If I can - I get weapon from this players and put to other players who go to waypoint, go front, and use weapons.
-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
My other facourite: I say as commander on supersiege: GL spam door with GL and HMGs defense the others, NO ATTACK to alien side". Door open, some marines have JP, all marines have HMG/GL and a lot of marines go to alien side an die without kill: aliens are camping on our side and kill all incomer marine... I see on radar I say this ten times and many many marines go to alien side, die and cannot kill aliens... And if I cannot put JP+hmg after 3-5 sec vote for me...
Intresting, a 20-40% of marine know what I said and no die + kill many aliens on door... But others do unlogical things and not do effective attacks...
-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
The next others, siege door opening:
If we rule the door, and the other side of map, I say as commander: "Only some player with HMG+JP go to siege room - Others STAY ON FRONT/position" - after siege door open, 30 sec or more...
If have normal players, this works: 3-5 marine with JP go to siege room and bulid fast and kill all aliens who come.
If no one normal player worst thing happen: only 1 or ALL marine go to siege door, and when only 1-2 siege up, we loose ALL RTs, door, and other place of map... And aliens kill the marine base, no res for weapons, HAs, and sometimes we loose...
-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
The "iconed" players is a normal/pro players and 90% play as smart/good/excellent.
The commander's nightmare: marines are lame, don't go to waypoint, no aim skill, no "brain" to play as smart...
-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
On after midnight or near morning play many "low skilled" marine and aliens... This time a tipical things happen:
marines build a very good defense: many TFs, etc...
Many times the TF kill aliens, not the marine...
Aliens slow down PGs and TFs... marines NOT REPAIR TFs, PGs... his save own life... and resources near out...
Siege door open: marines have JP/HA and HMG/GL but ONLY 1-2-3 FADE kill all marine army (!), all the 10-14 marine many times... No one have 1 marine who can kill 1-2 iconed fade alien players... Aliens rule the map... Marines have all upgrades, all weapons, all HAs JPs but cannot can kill the PRO player aliens...
And marines loose...
-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
Bye,
MoTi
PS.: This is my opinion only :-)